Duterte witness fails to discredit report

Photo: The Manila Times · Original story
THE defense team in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial continued to face rough sailing on Thursday when their witness admitted he had never read the prosecution’s forensic report on her alleged unexplained wealth, yet claimed he could identify problems in the financial analysis with just one look.Rainer dela Fuente, a former official of the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC), struggled to justify his assessment during the 44th day of Duterte’s Senate impeachment trial, with Senator-Judge Raffy Tulfo questioning how he could identify errors in a financial analysis he had neither received nor reviewed before taking the witness stand.Dela Fuente defended his assessment, saying his experience in financial investigations allowed him to spot potential problems almost immediately.“Although my stint at the agency was relatively short, I could already identify the problems just by taking a single look,” he said.“Wow! Just one look? You’re like a supercomputer,” Tulfo said. “How can you tell that there is a problem with the report when you haven’t even examined it for at least 10 minutes? You were only shown what appeared to be a few seconds of it, yet you were immediately able to form an opinion.”Dela Fuente said he had cross-checked the information against standard financial investigation procedures but clarified that he was not rejecting the entire forensic report.“I’m not discounting the entire report, just the portion shown to me,” he said.He added that the defense had asked him hypothetical questions following the presentation, so his answers were hypothetical as well.Tulfo maintained that dela Fuente should have examined the relevant documents before offering an expert assessment of the prosecution’s findings.Earlier, dela Fuente told the impeachment court that he had not received a copy of the 50-page forensic report prepared by prosecution witness and financial analyst Alexander Cabrera, or the supporting documents presented by the prosecution. He also admitted that he had not reviewed them before taking the witness stand.Defense counsel Mark Vinluan explained that the defense had opted to present the documents in open court rather than provide them to the subpoenaed witness beforehand. The defense intended to focus on selected portions of the report and discuss specific concepts instead of reviewing the entire document.Senator-Judge Joel Villanueva questioned how dela Fuente could challenge Cabrera’s findings without first examining the report, stressing that determining whether the findings were incorrect was ultimately a matter for the court.Tulfo also questioned how the witness could contradict the forensic expert without knowing what the report contained.“If he is going to refute the forensic expert witness without even being given a copy of the documents presented by that expert, then he should not be allowed to contradict or challenge the findings. In the first place, he has no idea what the witness actually said or what the documents contain,” Tulfo said.Dela Fuente maintained that he did not need to examine Cabrera’s specific report to discuss whether its findings were consistent with the provisions of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA).House prosecutor Chel Diokno questioned dela Fuente about the financial records submitted by banks and government agencies to the impeachment court.Diokno asked whether the witness was claiming that the records submitted by the AMLC were inaccurate or untruthful.“No, Your Honor,” dela Fuente replied.Diokno also asked whether he was alleging that documents submitted by the Bureau of Internal Revenue, Securities and Exchange Commission, and other government agencies had been tampered with or fabricated.“No, Your Honor,” the witness said.Asked whether he disputed the authenticity of the bank records submitted to the court, dela Fuente again answered, “No, Your Honor.”‘Give us more competent witnesses’Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo also questioned the value of dela Fuente’s testimony, noting that he had not examined suspicious transaction reports, covered transaction reports or other financial intelligence documents that could support or contradict the prosecution’s findings.“What is the value of his expertise if he has not even seen the documents? What is he going to testify about when everything is based on theory and his personal belief?” he asked.He urged the defense to present witnesses capable of directly addressing the prosecution’s evidence.“I know the defense can do better than this. In the coming days, perhaps you should bring in a witness who can really stand their ground,” he said.“The witnesses you have presented over the past few days have been somewhat weak,” he added.He called on the defense to bring in more competent and professional witnesses who could effectively challenge the prosecution’s claims and answer questions from the senator-judges.“Bring someone who is truly professional, someone who can rebut what the prosecution has presented and answer the questions,” he said.Senator-Judge Francis Pangilinan also questioned the probative value of dela Fuente’s testimony, given that he was answering hypothetical questions rather than addressing the evidence before the court.Dela Fuente explained that he had been called to testify on AML standards and how financial investigations are generally conducted.“That is the extent of my testimony, Your Honor,” he said.Presiding Officer Francis Escudero reminded the defense that Duterte was not facing a money laundering charge before the Senate impeachment court and did not need to be defended against an alleged violation of the AMLA.Escudero made the clarification after Diokno questioned the relevance of dela Fuente’s testimony, saying the impeachment allegations concerned Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth, nondisclosure of assets in her statement of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALN) and participation in business.Raffy Tulfo also questioned the relevance of presenting dela Fuente, arguing that extensive testimony on money laundering was unnecessary because Duterte was not facing such a charge.He pointed out that impeachment proceedings were among the exceptions to certain bank confidentiality restrictions under the AMLA and Republic Act 1405, or the Bank Secrecy Law.Tulfo questioned why the witness’ expertise was still necessary when the legal exceptions allowing the disclosure of bank information in impeachment cases had already been discussed during previous hearings.Dela Fuente confirmed that he was familiar with the Bank Secrecy Law and acknowledged that impeachment cases were among the exceptions to its restrictions on bank account disclosures.In a subsequent round of questioning, Tulfo asked about dela Fuente’s experience conducting money laundering investigations.Dela Fuente confirmed that he had handled such investigations and explained that applications for bank account freeze orders were filed ex parte before the Court of Appeals, subject to the necessary authority and approval.He also agreed that investigators must present evidence to justify a request to freeze an account.Senator-Judge Alan Peter Cayetano appealed to the impeachment court to give Duterte’s defense team more latitude in presenting its evidence, arguing that it should be afforded the same opportunity given to the prosecution.His appeal came after the defense played a video clip featuring the late senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago, prompting questions from several senator-judges about its relevance to the proceedings.Erwin Tulfo urged the defense team to “let the dead rest” after lawyers played archival video clips from the 2012 impeachment proceedings of the late Chief Justice Renato Corona.The manifestation occurred after Vinluan played footage from the 2012 trial featuring the late Defensor-Santiago speaking on the Senate floor, alongside excerpts from Corona’s own testimony.Tulfo immediately interrupted the presentation to question the relevance of the 14-year-old footage to the current charges against the vice president. Urging the defense to leave the deceased out of the proceedings, Tulfo maintained that invoking the statements of late figures from a separate historical trial had no bearing on the present case.Escudero sustained Tulfo’s position and immediately ordered the defense panel to halt the video presentation.Senator-Judge Panfilo Lacson also took the floor to back the objection, saying he saw no legal significance in projecting the past opinion of a single former senator-judge from the 2012 Corona trial onto the current tribunal.Cayetano said the prosecution had been given considerable time to present its witnesses, evidence and arguments, and the defense should likewise be allowed sufficient time to address the issues raised during the trial.He acknowledged that the prosecution had presented its case professionally, although the defense disagreed with some of its arguments.However, he stressed that impeachment proceedings were not purely judicial but also political in nature.Escudero reiterated that the defense was not being prevented from discussing AMLC-related evidence but should focus on the actual allegations in the impeachment articles.The unexplained wealth allegations stem from claims that Duterte’s accumulated assets and financial transactions were disproportionate to her lawful income as a public official and that some properties and financial interests were not properly disclosed in her SALNs.Duterte has held public office since 2007, serving as vice mayor and mayor of Davao City before becoming vice president in 2022. The impeachment allegations cover her financial declarations and transactions during her years in government service.The prosecution has relied on bank records, corporate documents, tax information and AMLC reports to support its allegations that Duterte and Carpio accumulated wealth that could not be adequately explained by their declared income.During earlier testimony, AMLC Executive Director Ronel Buenaventura told the impeachment court that Duterte and Carpio had a combined P4.4 billion in covered and suspicious bank transactions from 2007 to 2025.The figure represents transactions reported by banks to the AMLC. Covered transaction reports and suspicious transaction reports are distinct categories of financial reporting, and their aggregate amount does not automatically represent the couple’s personal wealth or establish that the funds came from illegal activities.
Read the full story at The Manila Times.



