Jeepney.io
Local · Nov 21, 2026 · The Manila Times

‘Cale88 opens up VP to tax fraud charges’

Photo: The Manila Times · Original story

A P568-MILLION discrepancy between Cale88 Foods Corp.’s declared sales and documented bank inflows raises questions about possible tax fraud and undeclared income, House prosecutors said Saturday, as they challenged Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense to explain the company’s questioned transactions.House prosecution spokesman and Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong said Cale88, linked to Duterte’s husband Manases Carpio, reported about P208 million in sales, while financial records presented by the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) showed about P776 million in inward remittances.At a news forum Saturday, Adiong cited the National Internal Revenue Code, which provides that a substantial underdeclaration of taxable sales or income exceeding 30 percent may constitute prima facie evidence of a false or fraudulent return.“Again, going back to the Tax Code, more than 30 percent of the income of your company that you have not declared or filed in your tax returns would constitute prima facie fraud,” he said.Adiong said the questioned remittances were documented bank transactions, including funds received from China and Hong Kong.“These are actual funds that entered the company’s accounts. They are not fabricated,” he said.During the impeachment trial against the vice president, prosecutors had presented financial records showing at least P319 million in inward remittances to Cale88 from China and Hong Kong, raising questions about the source and purpose of the transactions.House prosecution spokesperson Rep. Terry Ridon, in a separate interview with The Manila Times on Saturday, said the senator-judges had examined the discrepancy during the hearing and expected the defense to address it through its remaining witnesses.“During the hearing, the senator-judges were looking into the P700 million inflow remittances to Calle88, particularly the discrepancy between its P200 million reporting in its financial statement and the unreported remittance balance of P500 million,” Ridon said.“The DTI (Department of Trade and Industry) witness said that the firm’s executives are in the best position to explain the figures. The defense should address these questions going into its remaining sets of witnesses.”Adiong said the defense had yet to directly address the financial findings of lawyer and prosecution witness Alexander Cabrera, despite presenting several witnesses before the Senate impeachment court.The two witnesses presented Friday — Trade Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, managing head of the Board of Investments, and Food and Drug Administration Director Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan — focused on Cale88’s investment registration, business permits and product certifications.“What the witnesses have provided so far, these two they presented yesterday, is the regular processing of securing and obtaining a certification and permit to operate a company,” Adiong said.He said Pagayunan’s testimony established only that Cale88 manufactures banana chips, which did not address the central allegation under Article II of unexplained wealth.“What they presented was that there are banana chips manufactured by Cale88. Again, that is not the main point under Article II of unexplained wealth,” he said.Adiong said the defense should have directly challenged Cabrera’s findings instead of focusing on regulatory compliance, property assessments and individual expenses.“If their intention really is to change, refute or contradict Atty. Cabrera’s report, they should have successfully done that by presenting their first two or three witnesses,” he said.He maintained that the defense must explain the questioned transactions and alleged discrepancies in Duterte’s Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALNs).“Nothing they have presented so far would explain or shed light on the prosecution’s allegations,” he said.Dragging strategy?Adiong accused Duterte’s defense of possibly prolonging the impeachment trial by presenting witnesses whose testimonies have failed to address the financial evidence against the vice president.“We want to convey to our countrymen that, in our view, there seems to be a strategy to drag out this impeachment trial beyond what is necessary for the court to hear the testimony of those supposed witnesses they would present in the future,” he said.Adiong acknowledged the defense’s right to determine how and when to present its witnesses but said the proceedings should not be unnecessarily prolonged.Brand endorserMeanwhile, Adiong said the prosecution regretted the defense’s withdrawal of a witness from the Center for International Trade Expositions and Missions (CItem), who could have helped establish Duterte’s direct connection to Cale88.He said the prosecution intended to present a photograph of Duterte holding the company’s banana chips, which had been submitted to Citem.“It is unfortunate because the prosecution could have presented something that would link VP Sara Duterte directly to Cale88,” he said.Adiong said the photograph would show that Duterte’s connection to the company extended beyond her husband’s reported shareholding.“She is not merely the spouse of a stockholder, but she is also an endorser of this product,” he said.Adiong maintained that Duterte could not distance herself from the company, adding that she was interested in making Cale88 successful in its business ventures.The Manila Times sought comment from Duterte’s defense team but had yet to receive a response as of publication time.OVP denialThe Office of the Vice President (OVP) on Saturday denied any connection between its nationwide tree-planting campaign and Cale88 Foods Corp.’s compliance with a government requirement for businesses seeking incentives.The denial came a day after House prosecutors raised questions about Vice President Duterte’s participation in tree-planting activities, linking the initiative to the Board of Investments (BOI) requirements for Cale88.“Any attempt to link the vice president’s participation in the OVP’s environmental initiatives to Cale88 Foods Corp.’s BOI compliance is misleading, malicious, and has no factual basis,” the OVP said in a statement.The OVP said its “Pagbabago: A Million Trees Campaign” was launched on March 27, 2023, as an independent environmental initiative supporting the Department of Environment and Natural Resources’ efforts to reduce carbon emissions and address climate change.The campaign has planted 1,386,682 trees nationwide in partnership with government agencies and private-sector groups, it added.'Ego' may have been touchedBut Adiong defended the question, saying prosecutors wanted to establish whether a photograph of Duterte planting trees had been included in documents Cale88 submitted to meet the BOI’s tree-planting requirement.Adiong said the prosecution sought a categorical answer on the photograph’s possible connection to the company’s compliance documents, not to present the connection as an established finding.“But perhaps their egos were touched,” Adiong said during the Saturday News Forum in Quezon City. "So let us not be so onion-skinned,” he added.Adiong said scrutiny of photographs and other information was part of cross-examination, recalling that defense lawyers had also questioned prosecution witnesses on matters they considered relevant.During Friday’s hearing, private prosecutor Erwin Matib showed photos of Duterte planting trees and asked Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, who also heads the BOI, whether he knew the vice president was fond of planting trees.Matib linked the question to the BOI’s tree-planting requirement for companies seeking government incentives.Defense counsel Justin Gular objected, arguing there was no prior testimony connecting Duterte’s tree-planting activities to Cale88’s compliance.Senate President Francis Escudero allowed Matib to proceed but cautioned him to stay within the issue’s relevance.Adiong said the prosecution was not challenging the act of planting trees itself.“There is nothing wrong with complying with the tree-planting requirement,” he said. “What is wrong is the unexplained assets.”He said the prosecution remained concerned with income declarations and Cale88 transactions reflected in reports submitted to the Anti-Money Laundering Council, arguing that those issues required answers beyond the procedures for obtaining permits, certifications and incentives.Adiong also cited Carpio’s reported interest in Cale88 as a reason for directing questions at a photograph involving Duterte.He said prosecutors wanted to distinguish documents submitted for company compliance from material that may have been unrelated to the requirement.The OVP said the campaign was part of its advocacy to protect the environment for future generations, adding that it remained committed to delivering public service despite what it called political insinuations.Disrespecting the judgesAlso on Saturday, the House prosecution urged Vice President Duterte’s camp to respect the Senate impeachment court and its senator-judges, even when their statements or rulings go against the defense.Adiong made the appeal after the court issued a show cause order against Duterte’s spokesperson, lawyer Paolo Panelo, over remarks questioning the impartiality of several senator-judges.“Let us respect the position of each senator-judge because that is respect for the sacred process of this impeachment court,” Adiong said during the Saturday News Forum in Quezon City.He said the prosecution had also faced criticism from senator-judges, including remarks dismissing the findings of forensic accounting expert Alexander Cabrera as mere gossip.“But we respect their position and we never said anything that is combative or adversarial to what they have taken and what they have said,” Adiong said.The controversy stemmed from Panelo’s accusations of bias against some senator-judges during their questioning of defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council official.Panelo maintained that his criticisms were protected by his constitutional right to free speech.On Friday, the impeachment court ordered Panelo to explain his remarks. Presiding officer Sen. Francis Escudero clarified that while Panelo was not directly covered by the court’s sub judice rule, he could still face contempt proceedings under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court.Adiong said the incident should serve as a warning to everyone involved in the trial to observe proper decorum and respect the court.

Read the full story at The Manila Times.

Business, jobs and community in one placeJeepney.io is a free community with a marketplace, wallet, jobs and groups.Join Jeepney.io free Browse Jeepney Marketplace →

More Local

Seafarers urge compensation release after SC voids bond rulePhilippine Daily Inquirer · Nov 22, 2026Dizon to meet transport groups as Manibela readies 2-day strikePhilippine Daily Inquirer · Nov 22, 2026Cebu town implements water recycling amid El Niño threatPhilippine Daily Inquirer · Nov 21, 2026Negros Occidental to host global organic agriculture meetPhilippine Daily Inquirer · Nov 21, 2026
Get Jeepney DailyTop headlines in your inbox each morning. Free. Unsubscribe any time.